DeepValue | The New Way Investors Work

AngloGold Ashanti has quietly turned into one of the biggest winners of the current gold bull run. Over the last twelve months, the stock has exploded roughly 280% to around $106, powered by record free cash flow, rapidly improving balance sheet strength, and a new commitment to paying out 50% of free cash flow as dividends.

On the surface, this looks like exactly the kind of high‑quality, cash‑gushing gold producer investors dream about. 2024 free cash flow jumped nine‑fold to $942 million, while Adjusted EBITDA grew 93% year over year to $2.747 billion as realized gold prices climbed to $2,394/oz and volumes stayed stable, according to the FY 2024 results (Feb 2025). Through Q3 2025, quarterly free cash flow reached a record $920 million and the company swung to a net cash position, as highlighted in the Q3 2025 earnings release.

But when we step back and look at the setup from a long‑term value perspective, the picture gets more complicated.

At ~24x trailing EPS and ~21x EV/EBITDA, the market is paying peak‑cycle multiples on what already looks like peak‑cycle earnings and margins. The business is firing on all cylinders in a gold price environment many banks expect to stay elevated, yet production is more or less plateauing, costs are drifting higher, and the dividend framework is deliberately pro‑cyclical.

From our vantage point, this is not the kind of risk/reward profile where you want to be adding aggressively. It’s the sort of name where you ask: “Am I late to the party, and if so, what’s my downside if the music slows?”

If you own or are considering AU, run a full deep-dive in minutes instead of spending days in filings and industry reports. Our platform ingests SEC filings automatically and surfaces the key risk/reward drivers for you.

See the Full Analysis →

In this breakdown, we’ll walk through why we currently tag AngloGold Ashanti as a potential sell at today’s price, what needs to go right for bulls from here, and where we see more attractive entry points for long‑term investors.

AngloGold Ashanti: From Turnaround Story to Cash Machine

AngloGold Ashanti is a global gold producer with a portfolio spanning Africa, the Americas and Australia, plus growth projects in Colombia, Côte d’Ivoire, Nevada and elsewhere. Its current cash engine is increasingly concentrated in Tier‑1 and Tier‑2 assets like Geita, the ramping Obuasi mine in Ghana, and the recently acquired Sukari mine in Egypt.

According to Energy Capital Power (Jun 2025), management is spending over $1 billion to modernize Obuasi and lift it toward 400,000 ounces per year by 2028, while Zacks’ coverage via Nasdaq (Aug 2025) highlights Sukari’s potential to approach 500,000 ounces per year. Together, these mines are intended to form the backbone of AngloGold’s next decade.

The strategic pivot of the last few years has been significant:

The company redomiciled and shifted its primary listing to the NYSE in 2023, later joining the Russell 1000, 3000 and Midcap indexes in 2025, per the Russell index press release.
It acquired Centamin in late 2024, bringing Sukari into the portfolio and signaling a move away from mature, deep Australian underground mines toward larger African ore bodies.
It has been openly weighing the sale of assets like Tropicana and Sunrise Dam in Western Australia, as discussed in The Australian (Sep 2025).

The net result is a company that has gone from “turnaround candidate” to “sector leader and cash machine” in the eyes of the market. Recent coverage, from TipRanks (Jan 2026) to Nasdaq price target updates (Nov 2025), frames it as a high‑beta winner of the gold up‑cycle.

That shift in narrative is important: once a stock is no longer under‑the‑radar, expectations – and downside risks – change.

What’s Driving Today’s Earnings Power?

To understand the stock’s risk/reward, we first need to unpack what’s actually driving AngloGold’s surge in earnings and free cash flow.

Gold Price vs. Operational Improvement

From 2023 to 2024, gold income rose from $4.48 billion to $5.673 billion, even though ounces sold were broadly flat. The key driver was realized price increasing from $1,930/oz to $2,394/oz, as detailed in the FY 2024 results (Feb 2025).

Free cash flow’s nine‑fold jump to $942 million in 2024 was therefore overwhelmingly price‑driven rather than the result of a step‑change in costs or volumes. In fact:

2024 production barely grew, from 2.644Moz to 2.661Moz.
All‑in sustaining costs (AISC) ticked up from $1,657/oz to $1,672/oz, with Africa’s AISC at $1,709/oz.
2025 guidance points to group AISC rising further into the $1,580–1,705/oz band due to higher sustaining capex and royalty‑linked costs, as noted in the Q1 2025 release.

So while management has clearly executed well operationally, the extraordinary earnings power we see today rests heavily on a structurally higher gold price environment.

J.P. Morgan expects gold to stay strong into 2026, as summarized in its Global Research on gold prices (Dec 2025), and MoneyWeek (Jan 2026) notes spot gold near $4,690/oz after a huge run in 2025. Consensus 2026 forecasts compiled by Lear Capital (Jan 2026) sit around $4,400–5,300/oz.

If that holds, AngloGold will continue to print very high margins. But valuation needs to price in what happens if those forecasts prove too optimistic.

AISC and Capex Are Drifting Higher

The other key dynamic is cost and capital intensity.

In Q2 2025, AISC rose to $1,666/oz, up 7% year‑over‑year, driven by a 28% increase in sustaining capex and inflationary pressure, as outlined in the Q2 2025 release. Management is spending to stabilize operations, improve reliability, and push critical assets like Obuasi and Sukari along their ramp‑up paths.

We view that as rational capital allocation. But it also means the breakeven gold price at which AngloGold can sustain production, replace reserves, and maintain safety standards is creeping higher. If gold prices flatten or roll over, this rising AISC base becomes a problem quickly.

Is AU Stock a Buy in 2026, or Time to Trim?

This is the question most investors are wrestling with: is AngloGold still a buy after such an explosive move, or does the prudent value investor start taking chips off the table?

Our current stance is Potential Sell, with an explicit bias toward trimming exposure or avoiding new purchases at current levels.

Here’s why.

Valuation: Peak Multiples on Peak Earnings

At a share price around $106, AngloGold trades at:

Roughly 24x trailing P/E
Around 20.7x EV/EBITDA

These are peak‑cycle, growth‑stock‑style multiples being applied to a highly cyclical business that has just benefited from a historic surge in its underlying commodity.

In our base case, where gold prices remain strong (mid‑$4,000s/oz), production holds roughly flat around 3.0Moz, and AISC stays within guidance, we see fair value around $100 per share. That’s modestly below the current price and assumes no major negative surprises.

The issue is not that the base case is terrible – it’s actually quite healthy. The problem is that upside from here looks limited compared to the downside if the cycle turns or if execution wobbles.

Our scenario framework:

Base case (45% probability)

Implied value: $100
Gold stays strong, production ~3.0Moz, AISC in guidance band.
Margins stay high, but they don’t expand meaningfully.

Bear case (35% probability)

Implied value: $70
Gold averages closer to $3,500/oz, AISC creeps above $1,800/oz, and production dips below 2.9Moz.
Margins compress sharply, free cash flow falls, and the dividend resets lower.

Bull case (20% probability)

Implied value: $130
Gold averages near $5,000/oz and both Sukari and Obuasi outperform, pushing production above 3.2Moz at stable AISC.
This is the “everything goes right” scenario.

When we weigh those outcomes, the current price embeds something closer to the high side of the base case. You’re not being paid much to take on the risk that gold drifts down or production disappoints.

Limited Margin of Safety

The combination of:

Peak‑cycle commodity pricing
Rising sustaining capex and AISC
A variable dividend that is explicitly tied to free cash flow and leverage

means there is no real margin of safety in the current valuation.

The strong balance sheet – net debt/EBITDA around 0.28x on a market‑cap basis, interest coverage ~17x, and an adjusted net cash position by Q3 2025 – is a genuine positive, as highlighted in the Q3 2025 release. But that protects solvency, not your entry multiple.

If gold prices revert toward AngloGold’s AISC band of $1,580–1,705/oz for any sustained period, the company can survive. Shareholders who bought at 24x earnings likely won’t enjoy the ride.

If you hold several gold names, use our parallel engine to analyze 10+ tickers side by side and see which actually justify their multiples under different gold scenarios.

Run Deep Research on AU →

Will AngloGold Ashanti Deliver Long-Term Growth?

The next piece of the puzzle is volume and cost outlook. Can AngloGold grow or at least sustain production and margins through 2026 and beyond, justifying a premium multiple?

Production: Plateau, Not Breakout

Management and consensus currently expect 2025–2026 production in the 2.9–3.2Moz range. Guidance language for 2026 points toward “similar levels” rather than a material step‑up, based on commentary in the company’s filings and earnings calls summarized in our report.

That means the story into 2026 is more about:

Replacing ounces from any Australian asset sales
Successfully ramping Obuasi and Sukari
Keeping AISC contained

than it is about explosive production growth.

If investors are paying a growth multiple, they should recognize they’re doing so for a plateauing production base with rising costs, not a clear path to structurally higher volumes.

Ramp Risks at Obuasi and Sukari

Obuasi and Sukari are central to AngloGold’s long‑term narrative.

Obuasi is being modernized with a new shaft and infrastructure, targeting ~400koz/year by 2028, per Energy Capital Power (Jun 2025).
Sukari has the potential to reach 450–500koz/year at scale, as discussed by Zacks via Nasdaq (Aug 2025).

Execution here has been solid, but not without challenges. Prior issues at Obuasi – including brittle ground conditions – required changes in mining methods, which management has addressed by adopting a hybrid approach and investing in infrastructure, according to company filings.

Our worry isn’t that Obuasi or Sukari fail outright; it’s the risk of:

Cost overruns and higher sustaining capex
Slower‑than‑planned ramps
Operational hiccups or regulatory friction in key jurisdictions

Any combination of these could erode the production plateau narrative and put pressure on the dividend and multiple.

Dividend Policy: Attractive But Pro‑Cyclical

One of the biggest magnets for investors has been AngloGold’s refreshed dividend framework.

As outlined in the Q1 2025 6‑K filing (Mar 2025), the board has committed to:

A base dividend of $0.50 per share through the cycle, plus
A variable top‑up equal to 50% of free cash flow when adjusted net debt/EBITDA is at or below 1.0x.

In 2024 and 2025, that formula produced eye‑catching payouts because free cash flow exploded and the balance sheet strengthened. Late‑2025 and early‑2026 coverage, from TipRanks to FinancialContent’s summary of the Q3 2025 dividend declaration, repeatedly emphasize this 50% of FCF payout as a key part of the bull case.

We like the transparency and leverage discipline embedded in this framework. But there are two realities investors should keep in mind:

1. The variable component is explicitly pro‑cyclical. If gold prices fall or capex rises, free cash flow shrinks and so does the variable dividend.

2. Management retains discretion. The framework is not a fixed promise; it is subject to board judgment in the context of growth capex, M&A, and balance sheet considerations.

For us, the upcoming FY 2025 dividend “true‑up” will be a critical test. If total 2025 dividends materially undershoot 50% of annual free cash flow while leverage remains well below 1.0x, that will signal a softening of the policy and undermine the “cash‑machine” narrative.

Sentiment: From Contrarian Pick to Crowded Trade

Valuation and fundamentals are only half the story; sentiment and positioning matter, especially at cyclical peaks.

Over the past year, AngloGold has shifted from being viewed as a relative value play in gold miners to a consensus high‑beta winner:

Multiple brokers have raised price targets into the $80–$130 range, as tracked by Nasdaq (Nov 2025) and American Banking News (Dec 2025).
Call‑option activity has surged, with one late‑November session seeing over 15x typical contract volumes, per American Banking News (Nov 2025).
Articles in Investors Business Daily (Nov 2025) and Investing.com (Oct 2025) highlight the stock’s all‑time highs and outperformance vs. both gold and peers.

Crowded trades can keep working for a while, especially when macro tailwinds remain supportive. But they also become fragile. If gold prices pause, if 2026 guidance disappoints, or if AISC creeps above guidance, a lot of “hot money” can try to exit at once.

From a risk‑management perspective, we’d rather be early in these cycles than late.

Key Risks That Could Hurt Shareholders From Here

For current or prospective shareholders, we think about risks in three main buckets: macro, operational, and policy/structural.

1. Macro: Gold Price Normalization

This is the obvious one, but it’s still central.

A sustained move in gold toward $3,500/oz – still historically high – would compress AngloGold’s margins sharply. With AISC already in the mid‑$1,600s and trending higher due to sustaining capex and royalties, a lower gold price environment could:

Force cuts to sustaining capex or growth projects
Trigger reserve write‑downs or mine closures at higher‑cost sites
Reduce or suspend the variable dividend, and potentially put pressure even on the $0.50 base over time

This is effectively our bear case: fewer ounces at a tighter margin, on a multiple that was set assuming the good times would roll.

2. Operational & Execution Risk

The most important watchpoints we’re tracking:

2025 production vs. guidance: Management has guided to 2.900–3.225Moz for 2025. If FY 2025 results or 2026 guidance come in materially below “similar levels,” that weakens the case for a stable high‑2M/low‑3M oz production base.
AISC and sustaining capex: Any sustained move above the top end of 2025 guidance ($1,705/oz) without clear offsetting improvements in grade or recoveries would be a red flag.
Obuasi and Sukari ramp progress: Missed throughput, grade, or cost milestones at these flagship assets would undermine the growth narrative laid out in Energy Capital Power (Jun 2025) and Zacks via Nasdaq (Aug 2025).

3. Policy, Tax and Cash-Conversion Risk

AngloGold operates in several jurisdictions with evolving fiscal and capital‑control regimes. Filings note:

VAT lock‑ups in Tanzania
Capital controls in Argentina
Repatriation constraints in the DRC

These dynamics can create a wedge between accounting free cash flow and cash actually available for dividends or reinvestment. Additionally, major adverse tax or royalty changes in key countries like Ghana (Obuasi), Tanzania (Geita), or Egypt (Sukari) could lift AISC structurally above current guidance.

For a stock that is being bought aggressively for its dividend and free‑cash‑flow story, these are not trivial risks.

What Would Make Us More Positive on AU?

Our current call is Potential Sell with a re‑assessment window of 6–12 months. That doesn’t mean we’re permanently bearish; it means we don’t believe today’s price adequately compensates for the risks in front of us.

We’d become more constructive if we saw a combination of:

Gold holding near or above $4,000/oz, and
2025–2026 results showing sustained EPS growth >15% with flat or improving AISC, and
Smooth ramps at Obuasi and Sukari, with clear progress toward their 400koz/500koz trajectories, and
Evidence that the 50% FCF payout is being honored consistently while maintaining a conservative balance sheet.

Equally, a pullback in the stock into the $80 range – our view of a more attractive entry point – without a collapse in fundamentals would start to rebuild the margin of safety we generally look for.

For investors scaling research across many cyclical names, this is exactly where tools like DeepValue can help: rapidly stress‑testing multiple tickers under different commodity price and cost scenarios to see which genuinely have downside protection.

If you want to go deeper on how to do that kind of systematic, scenario‑driven work, Read our AI-powered value investing guide.

Our Bottom Line for Long-Term Investors

Putting it all together, here’s how we frame AngloGold Ashanti today:

The business is in excellent shape operationally, with strong Tier‑1/Tier‑2 assets, a clean balance sheet, and well‑aligned incentives tied to free cash flow and costs.
The macro backdrop – a powerful gold bull market – has turned AngloGold into a cash‑flow machine, but also pulled forward a lot of value into today’s price.
Valuation now prices in a smooth continuation of 2024–2025 conditions, with limited room for disappointment on gold prices, costs, or production.

We see:

Base case fair value: ~$90–$100
Bear case: ~$70
Bull case (gold to ~$5,000/oz + flawless execution): ~$130

With the stock around $106, that’s not an asymmetric setup we’re eager to chase. For existing shareholders, we think it’s rational to:

Consider trimming into strength, especially if AU has grown into an outsized portfolio weight.
Tighten your monitoring of key catalysts: FY 2025 results and guidance, the 2025 dividend true‑up, and any concrete moves on Tropicana/Sunrise Dam.
Be ready to add back at lower prices or on evidence that production and cost performance are beating today’s high expectations.

For new money, we’d rather:

Wait for either a reset in price (sub‑$90), or
A convincing demonstration that AngloGold can deliver 15%+ EPS growth and maintain its dividend through a softer gold tape – not just during the boom.

Gold miners are, by nature, leveraged bets on the gold price. That can be highly rewarding through up‑cycles, especially for companies like AngloGold that have upgraded their asset base and balance sheet. But when earnings and free cash flow are this elevated, and when sentiment is this bullish, discipline matters more than ever.

Before you buy or trim AU, let our deep research agent pull every relevant SEC filing, production update, and industry source into a single, citation-backed report in minutes.

Start Researching Now →

AngloGold Ashanti (AU) Deep Research Report: Overvalued Gold Winner or Smart Hold Into the Next Cycle?